Summary
The article discusses the complexities of forgiveness related to the events and aftermath of September 11, 2001. The author, a former Guantanamo Bay detainee, argues that forgiveness should not be seen as an individual act, especially when it comes to addressing global-level harm and injustices. It highlights the challenges of forgiving without justice and the broader implications of such actions.
Key Facts
- The author was held at Guantanamo Bay for nearly 15 years without charges.
- They describe experiencing torture and dehumanization while in detention.
- The article criticizes the U.S. response to 9/11, including the invasions of Afghanistan and Iraq and the use of torture programs.
- A meal in Guantanamo contained a message stating "We Will Never Forget, We Will Never Forgive."
- The author was punished for responding to the message inside the meal box.
- The piece raises questions about the meaning of forgiveness in light of global atrocities committed in the fight against terrorism.
- The author argues that forgiveness needs to be collective and should not be given freely to unrepentant perpetrators.
- It examines the moral dilemma of expecting victims to forgive without accountability for their suffering.
