Account

The Actual News

Just the Facts, from multiple news sources.

Neil Gorsuch Says Supreme Court Just Made 'Broad New Legal Rule'

Neil Gorsuch Says Supreme Court Just Made 'Broad New Legal Rule'

Summary

The U.S. Supreme Court ruled on a case involving the legal process for federal prisoners to challenge their convictions. Justice Neil Gorsuch disagreed with the majority opinion, stating they made a new legal rule about the court's authority. The case centered on whether certain laws about reviewing prisoner motions apply the same way to state and federal prisoners.

Key Facts

  • The Supreme Court case is called Bowe v. United States.
  • The case discusses how federal prisoners can motion to vacate, or overturn, their convictions.
  • Justice Sonia Sotomayor wrote the majority opinion; five Justices agreed with her view.
  • The majority ruled that a statute about state prisoners does not apply to federal prisoners.
  • Justice Neil Gorsuch wrote a dissent, disagreeing with the majority's interpretation.
  • Gorsuch argued that federal and state prisoners should be treated the same under this statute.
  • The case affects how prisoners can challenge their sentences, specifically under the 28 U.S.C. laws.

Source Information